Skip to main content

Which is the most misunderstood film of all time?

Stay(2005) hands down
Stay (2005)




The story is about a Psychiatrist by the name Sam (McGregor) who’s a substitute shrink for Henry (Gosling). He’s in a relationship with a prior patient of his Laila (Naomi). Henry tells Sam that he plans of committing suicide in 3 days. Thus starts Sam’s efforts to get Henry to drop the idea.



Let’s stop for a bit here and jump down to the explanation of what the film was about. If you haven’t watched it, I suppose you should watch before reading.

The Explanation

There are two stories in the movie. I’ll call them "The Real" and "The Imagined".

The Real

Henry, his dad, mom and girlfriend are on the Brooklyn Bridge. Henry is driving the car. His car’s front tyre bursts and the car flips into a massive tumble and blows up. This is the start of the movie. Now cut to the end. Henry’s dad, mom and girlfriend are all dead. Henry is barely alive. There is a lady (by the name Elizabeth Levy) who says she was right behind the accident. She also says - I didn't touch him; I know you're not supposed to move them. He’s attended to by Sam a doctor and Laila a nurse. Sam and Laila have never met, they are just there offering help (Yes, they have never met).

They try to keep him alive till the ambulance gets to them. There are a whole bunch of bystanders watching Henry’s situation. Henry apologises for what he has done. He feels he has resulted in the death of his family. Sam tells him that the fault was not Henry’s as the tyre blew and nothing could have been done. Henry sees his girlfriend in the face of the nurse Laila and proposes to her. Laila says yes because she knows what is happening. Henry is fading away and is filled with guilt of what he’s done. Sam and Laila do their best but can do nothing but watch Henry die. The ambulance arrives, clears up the place. Henry asks Laila for a coffee as they both feel they will not be able to sleep anyways. The movie ends.




What? Then what about the whole movie you ask? The entire film apart from the Brooklyn Bridge accident, is what is…

The Imagined

After the accident, Henry’s mind is drawing up a more elaborate story. His mind draws on the characters that are present as bystanders watching him lying on the bridge. Since Sam and Laila are the ones helping him stay alive, his mind makes Sam his shrink. (Eliza)Beth Levy, who is the first one to see the accident from “The Real” segment, backs off after Sam steps in. Henry’s mind makes Beth Levy his first shrink and Sam her replacement. He imagines Laila as Sam’s girlfriend. The neighbour’s crying baby is simply a baby in a nearby car from “The Real”

Henry claims to have killed both his parents and is upset that he set fire to his car (this is the reference to the car blowing up in “The Real”). Henry explains how he is always hearing voices. Henry repeats the voices he’s hearing. These are nothing more than conversations that the bystanders are having in the “The Real”. Henry tells Sam that he plans on committing suicide in three days, when he turns 21.

Later Sam is playing chess with his blind mentor Leon. Leon is actually Henry’s father in “The Real”. This is why Henry freaks out looking at Leon and claim that he’s his father and is dead already.

Sam gets worried and tries to locate Beth Levy to find out more about Henry. Unable to find her anywhere he reaches her apartment where she’s sitting lost and wrapped in quilt. She says - I didn't touch him; I know you're not supposed to move them. This again is a dialogue in “The Real”.

Sam located Henry’s mother’s place where she lives with her dog. Henry’s mother confuses Sam for Henry. Then, bizarrely she starts bleeding and goes away, while the dog bites Sam. I’m not sure what the dog was doing there but Henry’s mom bleeding like that is basically a representation of how she had bled out in “The Real”. Sam then tries to explain to the cop that Henry’s mother is alive. The cop is nothing more than a bystander too in “The Real”. Notice Sam’s shot trousers? They are short in “The Imagined” because in “The Real”, Sam is sitting down and that causes his trousers to ride up.

Sam runs into Henry at his own house and there is a confusing altercation. Sam and Henry and arguing but are shown to swap roles. This is to give a hint to the audience that Sam and Henry are but one and the same. All of this is happening inside of Henry’s head.

Sam then tries to find Athena whom Henry was in love with. This is the girlfriend in “The Real”. She is in the reading of the play Hamlet. She agrees to take Sam to Henry but when Sam follows Athena down those painful winding stairs, he trips falls and loses her. When he goes back up, he sees the same scene of Athena reading the play Hamlet. This type of repeating sequences happen a couple of times earlier too. When Sam sees the same kid lose the balloon again. When he enters his house and hugs Laila and walks to the bed. All of this can be attributed to Henry’s brain shutting down in “The Real” because he’s losing so much blood.

Henry also happens to meet Leon and gets him his eye sight back and tells him he is his son. This scene is a little philosophical. It’s more about how he wants his father to see him for who he is. His guilt of killing his family in “The Real” has made his father turn a blind eye, literally, in “The Imagined”. This scene is Henry apologizing to his dad for his death. Didn’t make much sense, doesn’t matter, carry on.

From a bookstore that Henry frequently visits, Sam learns that Henry’s favourite artist had killed himself on his 21st birthday on the Brooklyn Bridge. This gives Sam the required clue and runs to the Brooklyn Bridge. Meanwhile, Henry is looking at some wedding rings and is intercepted by all the characters from “The Imagined”. Henry also starts bleeding from his head just like his mother does. All the characters in “The Imagined” are merely bystanders look on at Henry in “The Real”. In this scene, Henry is slowly perceiving what is actually happening.

All of this finally takes us to the scene where Henry and Sam are on the Brooklyn Bridge and Sam is telling Henry that this is all a dream. Henry puts the gun into his mouth and pulls the trigger. At this point “The Imagined” merges with “The Real”. In short “The Imagined” version is all cooked up in Henry’s dying head. Henry pulling the trigger in “The Imagined” is him giving up and dying in “The Real”.

What are those flashes that Sam sees when he asks Laila out for coffee?

Henry is proclaimed dead (no more pulse) but his brain cells are still dying away. Those flashes when Sam asks Laila for coffee are still what is happening in Henry's head. Those are the last few flashes based on Sam asking Laila out.

Stay is perhaps the most misunderstood film ever films like fight club or 2001 a space odyssey which initially got very poor reviews and were a box offfice flop foumd a new life on vhs or video on demand and have since gained a culy following but stay till this date is unable to get the recognition it deserves

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Human Shaped Roots of Chinese Plant

Have you ever seen a plant that is a root cause of human-shaped?  The root of the plant in China, a special kind of human being is like a mannequin. This plant is known. Usually it does not come from the plant's roots so obvious human shape, but Chinese plants is different from the other plant due to its similar properties.  The name of the plant and its roots when Flisflavar are fully developed and it is digging its shape resembles a human figure.  Their size can be estimated from the fact that it is a man or woman. The plant is very demanding in the whole China. It is in making medicines. Like Ayurveda is the ancient Chinese medical science.  The detailed description of the medicinal use of plants roots.  India, like the old prescriptions infallible medicinal prescriptions are quite popular in China. It is used Flisflavar. The roots of the plant mainly serves as a panacea for kidney disease. Also falling hair, fragile b...

Rani Mukerji and her husband appear in public for the first time after marriage, see pic

Rani Mukherjee and Aditya Chopra with her husband has been significantly reduced. After filmmaker Aditya Chopra, Rani Mukherjee married twice but was caught on camera, but with Aditya Chopra, Rani has been seen for the first time. Living in hiding from the media cameras Aditya recently while hanging out with his wife Rani Mukerji were seen. As a reminder, Aditya keep themselves away from public attention. But recent years have shown that both the Rani and Aditya are visible simultaneously. In fact, Aditya and Rani in Mumbai's Bandra area were at a birthday party to attend. Black T-shirt and jacket in the photo wearing Aditya showed the Rani could be seen in the red dress. Aditya tries to hide this by looking at the camera, not the media. There was no pose. Aditya looked quite serious. The usually silent during the Rani appeared chirping. Rani Mukherjee's daughter's birthday recently Adira also became his first photograph. Yash Raj Films This photo was p...

Do you think BJP will win in UP elections after a poll survey gave it a clear win?

‘May be’ BJP can win coming UP elections. I am saying ‘may be’ because it has chance but it won’t be easy. Also, it depends on lot of factor at run time. I wish BJP to win this election. However, as a ‘realist evaluator’ I find this is hard to happen. In this answer I am trying to analyze this based on facts and data only without mixing too much of my wish/opinions. Please consider below two tables. They speak a lot. 1) No Wave: Except 2014 Loksabha elections, BJP performed poorly in all elections recently (few years) in UP. 2014’s outstanding win in UP (72/80 seats win) was result of Modi wave. This Modi wave was created by Modi’s own popularity, his claimed good work in Gujarat, BJP’s organized efforts, Congress government’s bad governance, policy paralysis, scams, blasts, inflation etc. There is no such reason in UP elections now. 2) No Scams: Akhilesh government did not involve so far in any scams unlike UPA government during 2004-2014. His own popularity (not party’s)...